Preparing for a Publishing Internship Interview, and Follow-Up Questions You Should Ask Your Employer

Getting an actual interview with your dream publisher, or with any publisher, lit mag, newspaper, etc., is more than half the battle. Without fully knowing what the internship coordinator, editorial assistant, or HR rep looks for in a cover letter, getting a callback could be likened to winning the lottery—a lottery with decent odds, admittedly, but still leaving too much up to chance. Now, at the interview section of the process, you have much more control over making a good impression and feeling out what the interviewer wants from his or her intern.

In short, don’t let your upcoming interview stress you out. Most interviews follow a very similar, easy structure that this blog post will help you to prepare for:

  1. General questions about your publishing goals and background
  2. Questions about your traits, problem solving, attitude, and likes
  3. Logistical details and questions about start dates and dress codes that you should resist the urge to focus on;
  4. A Q&A period about your prospective position and publisher, a deceptively important opportunity to reveal things about yourself.

Interview formats

Interviews range in duration and style of questioning depending on the format of the interview. You may be questioned by the internship coordinator, the editorial/ production/ marketing assistants directly above you, an HR representative, or an assortment of each. See if you can discern from their emails—or directly ask if an in-person interview is preceded by a preliminary phone interview—the format of the interview and who will be questioning you, as this information can be extremely helpful in determining how to prepare for an interview.

For my seasonal (3 month) internship interviews, the number of interviewers ranged from 1-3, but the number didn’t matter. One person, usually your eventual supervisor, will take the lead on the majority of questions, while the remainder may have a question or two but generally aren’t as prepared or aware of your qualifications.

For a year-long salaried position I applied for, I ended up speaking with a dozen or so people in a three-round interview with editorial assistants, editorial department heads, and their HR representative. Fortunately, this interview was simply a longer, repetitious version of shorter interviews, with almost entirely the same questions coming up in each segment of the interview.

General Questions

Be ready for variations on the standard questions that come up in almost every interview:

i. Describe your interest in book publishing. Why are you interested in a career in editing?

ii. How have your past experiences/internships prepared you for this position? How are you qualified for this position?

iii. Why are you interested in this internship/working for publisher name here specifically?

iv. How are you a good fit for this position/company?

v. What do you hope to get out of this position?

The first two to three questions of an interview are usually these, so these questions will decide the first impression you make on the interviewer. I can’t help you in terms of avoiding nervousness and exuding confidence, but I can advise you on the content of your responses.

First, try to strike a balance between why they’re a good fit for you and why you’re a good fit for them. These questions naturally invite self-centered answers, but don’t spend too much time explaining how this internship will advance your career or why X publisher has always seemed so interesting (though this personal touch is still important). If the internship listing/webpage had a list of everyday tasks, describe how your work for them will supplement the skills you already have—a chance to praise yourself while showing your awareness of what the job entails and what you will and won’t need to learn on the job.

Similarly, if the internship is in the same field as past positions on your resume, explain how old experiences prepare you for this position while explaining how this position is somehow different or better for your career than past jobs. And most importantly, try to describe your general interest in the profession as well as your specific interest in the position. If you explain your interest in a career in editing or your love of the publishing industry, you show that the position is more than a line on your resume, which makes you a more attractive candidate.

Memorizing Anecdotes

You will then likely be asked two styles of questions: describe a situation at work that shows certain qualities or problem solving, and state certain accomplishments you are proud of. I lump these categories together because in either case you should have a selection of anecdotes ready to answer such questions as the following:

  1. What is your greatest strength/weakness? Don’t just state a quality for each. For your strength, give a short anecdote that exemplifies your strength. If you choose leadership, be sure you have something on your resume that actually tested your mettle. For your weakness, describe a moment where you realized you had a weakness in that area and how you are now working to fix that weakness, or are at least aware of it. They will appreciate the honest assessment, particularly if it is an area they specified on the job description like organization, multi-tasking, customer service, independence, or other common qualities you feel uncomfortable with.
  2. Describe a moment you dealt with a difficult supervisor/colleague/customer and how you solved the problem. This question has almost always come up for me, especially in editorial positions where my job is to email or speak with authors on a regular basis. Have an anecdote ready for each of these if possible, but be sure to focus more on your patience and graciousness rather than how much you hated your boss or hate annoying customers—unless the story is hilarious or absurd, in which case draw it out! It never hurts to show you have a sense of humor about these things, and your interviewer will likely empathize and have similar stories from their own time in your position. I’ve also had two different internships give me writing prompts asking me to respond to an angry customer to diffuse the situation, one as part of the application and one during the interview.
  3. Describe a time you worked as a team/led a team. You should hopefully have a good anecdote from a non-work source for this type of question, like participating with a literary magazine, community service group, school group project (that has to do with publishing, hopefully), or other examples.
  4. Describe a time that you had to multitask/prioritize; describe how you plan or organize your day. This question speaks for itself. Basically, your employer wants to know that you can handle the pressure of having multiple jobs to get done at once and that you know how to prioritize, both at work and in your everyday life.
  5. What are you most proud of/what is your greatest accomplishment? As I mentioned in my very first post about what not to say during an internship interview, be careful about what you would choose here, and have something prepared. It doesn’t necessarily have to pertain to publishing, though it certainly doesn’t hurt. For instance, if you describe how proud you were to have your name on the masthead of your college’s lit mag, you can use that to segue back into your passion for publishing. However, you can certainly use something else so long as it shows qualities that your employer will want in his or her intern.

Miscellaneous Questions

  • What are some of your favorite books/authors?
  • What blogs/newspapers/publishing websites do you read?
  • What do/did you study in school and how did it prepare you for this position?
  • What writing experience do you have?
  • What is your dream job/where do you want to be in five years?
  • Are there any others you’ve run into that I’ve missed? If so, feel free to post them in the comments and I’ll add them!

Questions to Ask Your Employer

For a good summary of the types of questions that impress interviewers, check out this thorough article by College Magazine. But to summarize, think hard about what you need to know during the interview phase. Some typical questions you might ask—what is the dress code, what will my average day consist of, when will I have your answer, can I take the internship for college credit—don’t tell the interviewer anything about you and bog things down. The interviewer may give you some of that information later anyway, and you can always figure out the office dress code and work culture on the job, or email about college credit or other logistics.

Instead, take the time to focus on the two people in the room, as well as the people that have been there before. Ask about how this will benefit your future career, specifically if this will prepare you for an entry-level position. As a follow-up, ask what other interns moved on to do, to see if they have found the kind of success you are looking for. Then feel free to shift the flow of the conversation toward the interviewer: how did they get involved in publishing/this publisher, and what is their specific job at the company? The above article notes that “interesting questions relating to background or questions showing that a candidate has researched and done his or her homework demonstrate passion and determination…[and]only a handful of people…[ask] personal questions.” Shining the spotlight on your future boss will show you the type or person you might work for, and allows them the chance to talk about themselves while giving you some breathing room as the interview winds down.


All of this information collected together may appear daunting, and there’s no way to predict every single question that a given editor will care to ask about. But that doesn’t matter as much as you simply coming into the interview with these key assets: a clear self-appraisal of what you want out of this internship and your future career, knowledge about the publisher and its books/authors, a series of personal stories that show your skills, experience, growth, and areas for improvement, and some questions that show your initiative and priorities.

I hope this was helpful for you! My next non-current events post will cover how to get relevant, non-internship publishing experiences outside of publishing hub cities like New York and Boston that you can use for those pesky anecdotal/situational questions.

Thanks for reading!

5 Things You Should Never Say at an Editorial Internship Interview

If you’re reading this blog, you probably have already decided that you want to become an editor, and you have your own reasons for this ridiculous life decision. So as a fellow editor who basically stumbled into the profession out of a love of books before truly learning about the profession, here are some things you really shouldn’t say at an interview if you don’t want to look like an amateur (note, most of these statements are things I’ve said myself in the past, so any mocking tone is mainly directed inward):

1. Interviewer: Why did you decide to interview for the position/become an editor?

“I grew up reading books and just loved them so much that—”

Let me stop you there. First off, no one in their right mind would become an editor if they didn’t love books. Out of all publishing jobs out there, the editorial assistant is the most competitive (I don’t have statistics for this, but word of mouth from several publishing professionals I’ve met has made this abundantly clear) and does not pay that well. So saying you love books lets them know you will fit in with the rest socially, but it doesn’t show your qualifications or set you apart from other interviewees. More importantly, a lot of positions don’t actually have you doing much reading. You won’t convince them that you deserve a position involving editing, administrative work, and so forth through your love of reading.

If you are interviewing for a genre imprint of a house or a specialized publisher, it does make sense to praise their backlist titles or author list—describe how much you rely on cookbooks every day before interviewing with Harvard Common Press, or describe your love of N.K. Jemisen and Mira Grant before going after a job with Orbit. But that only explains why you want to work for them, not why you want to be an editor in general. The distinction is important, and you’ll want to cover both topics if you can.

2. Why do you want to intern at this YA romance/poetry/cookbook imprint?

“Well, I don’t really know anything about YA romance, but I want to work here because HarperCollins is such a great publisher…”

Even if an internship doesn’t have you working with actual content, editors will prefer someone who will bring enthusiasm for the subject matter. To get through the most tedious chores like compiling Excel spreadsheets and updating Filemaker databases, you need patience and enthusiasm for your work—the idea that this work will help generate books you would enjoy reading yourself. While you definitely shouldn’t outright lie about loving literary nonfiction or romance, you might consider not applying in the first place if an editor will sense your apathy or lack of respect for the genre.

3. What’s your goal for this internship?

“A job.”

Internships are a great opportunity to make contacts, gather editorial experience,  build your resume, and potentially explore other departments besides editorial. And some publishers like Pearson do sometimes have their interns directly transition into editorial assistant positions. But most publishing houses see an internship as a quid pro quo rather than recruitment: interns get academic credit and experience, the house gets free labor from a smart college student. Being a good intern for three months does not entitle you to an automatic position, and this response may convince them that you aren’t willing to put in time on menial tasks, or that you might even be overqualified for the position.

4. What is your greatest accomplishment to date?

“I had a story published in X literary magazine”

I gave this response while interviewing for a literary magazine internship, and while I ended up getting the position I knew even then this was the wrong answer. Marketing and social media interns do more actual writing than editorial interns, who often focus on administrative/clerical/customer service duties. Your accomplishment doesn’t have to be editorial, but it should show qualities that the job listing specifies, such as leadership, organization, time management, etc. Plus, not all publications are created equal. Unless your story was published in a mag like Ploughshares or Tin House, editors at a literary magazine will look down on your accomplishment more than most.

5. Describe a moment when you were a leader/overcame an obstacle/etc.

“Is it all right if it has nothing to do with editorial work?”

Don’t be self-conscious about describing your work as an English tutor, B&N bookseller, or McDonalds cashier when it comes to describing your best qualities. Jump straight into the best example that shows you in a good light regardless of the circumstances, and have a few anecdotes, preferably funny or memorable ones, that show you to be a strong, professional person. I spent too much time being self-conscious about my lack of editorial experience when I applied for my first one, and asking this question merely called attention to that fact.


Hopefully this will help awkward people like me to avoid the common pitfalls in this type of interview. I can do another post about typical interview questions or how to prepare before an interview if anyone finds this to be helpful.

Thanks for reading!